Store
|
Contributing Editors
|
Help
|
Contact
|
Sign In
select
All
Images Only
Search
home
resources
images
handouts
videos
quizzes
boardreview
atoz
< Current issue
Dermatopathology: Practical & Conceptual July - September 2002
>
Flawed Concept: Staging of Melanoma: A Critique in Historical Perspective
Bradley Bakotic, D.O.
A. Bernard Ackerman, M.D.
Abstract
Introduction
Systems of Staging in Chronologic Sequence: L.V. Ackerman and Delgato (1947)
Sylven (1949)
American Joint Committee on Cancer (1962–1965)
McNeer and Das Gupta (1964)
M.D. Anderson Cancer Center (1976)
American Joint Committee on Cancer (1977)
Union Internationale Contre Le Cancer (1978)
American Joint Committee on Cancer (1983)
American Joint Committee on Cancer and Union Internationale Contre le Cancer (1988, 1992, 1997)
American Joint Committee on Cancer (2000, 2001)
“Evolution” in Staging is Paralleled by Devolution in Critical Thought
References
SEE ALSO
-
melanoma
-
metastatic melanoma
<
Previous
|
Next
>
American Joint Committee on Cancer and Union Internationale Contre le Cancer (1988, 1992, 1997)
In 1988, the AJCC and the UICC, in an effort to standardize systems for staging, recommended jointly a four-tier system in which two changes were of note.
13
First, in this revised system the size of a lymph node affected by metastasis need only be 3 cm, rather than 5 cm, in order to qualify as Stage IV. Second, in Stages I and II, Breslow's thickness trumped Clark's level when any discrepancy existed between them. No reason was given for downsizing a lymph node that harbored a metastasis; the reason for the triumph of Breslow's thickness over Clark's levels was said to be evidence statistically. The system devised jointly was revised again in 1992
14
and then again in 1997,
15
at which time it was propounded that Breslow's thickness should not automatically override Clark's level, but rather in situations where there were discrepancies between them, the figure associated with the least favorable prognosis should prevail.
<
Previous
|
Next
>
This site is made possible in part by:
Copyright © Derm101.com. All Rights Reserved.